The Orvis trout fly reel you described—made in England, 3.5 inches in diameter, and gently used—is likely a classic model from Orvis’s older lineup, possibly from the Battenkill, CFO (C. Farlow & Co.), or Farleigh series, which were well-regarded English-made reels. Here’s how to narrow it down:
Key Details to Identify the Model:
1. “Made in England” Markings:
– Orvis reels manufactured in England were often produced by J.W. Young & Sons (Redditch) or Hardy Bros. (for some CFO models).
– Look for additional markings (e.g., “Battenkill,” “CFO,” or “Farleigh”) on the reel foot, backplate, or spool.
2. 3.5-Inch Diameter:
– This suggests a larger trout/salmon reel (typical trout reels are 2.75–3.25 inches).
– Possible models:
– Battenkill Large Arbor (English-made, pre-2000s).
– CFO V or VI (larger sizes for 5–8 wt lines).
– Farleigh Salmon/Steelhead Reel (if heavier duty).
3. Design Features:
– Battenkill: Simple, durable, often with a black or olive finish, click drag.
– CFO: Lighter, more ornate (spoked or ported backplate), often with a disc drag.
– Check if it’s a “disc drag” or “click-and-pawl” system.
4. Serial Numbers:
– Some English-made Orvis reels have serial numbers on the backplate (contact Orvis customer service with this for verification).
Estimated Value (Gently Used):
– Battenkill (English): $100–$250, depending on rarity.
– CFO (Hardy-made): $200–$400+ (larger sizes are collectible).
– Farleigh: $150–$300 (if salmon-sized).
Next Steps:
1. Inspect for Markings: Clean the backplate/foot with a soft cloth to reveal model names or logos.
2. Compare Photos: Search eBay or vintage fly reel forums (e.g., Fiberglass Flyrodders) for visual matches.
3. Contact Orvis: They may have archives for older reels.
If you can share photos or additional details (drag type, weight, line capacity), I can refine the ID further!